1.
FALSE ALARM: HOW THE MEDIA HELPS THE INSURANCE INDUSTRY
AND THE GOP PROMOTE THE MYTH OF AMERICA'S "LAWSUIT
CRISIS"
Last
December, Newsweek featured a cover package by Stuart
Taylor and Evan Thomas that blared: "Lawsuit Hell:
Doctors. Teachers. Coaches. Ministers. They all share
a common fear: being sued on the job." Paired with
a weeklong tie-in on NBC News and online chats on MSNBC.com,
the article claimed that because "Americans will
sue each other at the slightest provocation," the
country is suffering from an "onslaught of litigation"
that costs Americans $200 billion a year. Newsweek's "onslaught"
of lawsuits simply hasn't happened. According to the National
Center for State Courts, a research group funded by state
courts, personal injury and other tort filings, when controlled
for population growth, have declined nationally by 8 percent
since the 1975, and have been falling steadily in real
numbers since 1996. The numbers are even more dramatic
in places with rapid population growth, like Texas, where
the rate of tort filings fell 37 percent between 1990
and 2000. Even in liberal California, the rate of filings
has plummeted 45 percent over the past decade. And those
overly sympathetic juries Newsweek derides as so eager
to dole out big bucks to injured victims? In 2001, they
voted against plaintiffs in 75 percent of all medical
malpractice trials, according to the federal government's
Bureau of Justice Statistics (BJS).
-
Stephanie Mencimer, Washington Monthly, October 2004
For complete story, see
here
For
the facts about America's civil justice system, please
go to our newly-revised
AAJ Web page
|
2004
PRESIDENTIAL ELECTION |
2.
HOW WOULD BUSH, KERRY AFFECT LAWYERS?
"Reforms"
to the legal system have taken center stage in the campaign
between President George W. Bush and Sen. John Kerry,
and they continue to be a focus for attorneys and legal
lobby groups. "It's no secret that the Bush administration
has been extremely adverse to regular Americans' rights
and therefore the ability of lawyers to be of assistance
to people who have a negligence case, an asbestos claim
or want to be part of a class action," said American Association for Justice president Todd Smith of Chicago.
-
Reni Gertner, Lawyers Weekly USA, 09/27/2004 For complete story, click
here
AAJ
members who are interested in helping us counter the planned
assault on the legal rights of American families can contact
the Center for Justice and Democracy about obtaining and
airing on local television stations its 30-second TV spot,
"Trial Lawyers: The Last Line of Defense." You
may view the ad at: http://www.centerjd.org
3.
COURT REINSTATES TOUCHSCREEN VOTING LAWSUIT
Just
five weeks before Election Day, a federal appeals court
revived a lawsuit demanding that all Florida voters who
use touchscreen machines receive a paper receipt, in case
a recount becomes necessary. The 11th U.S. Circuit Court
of Appeals told a federal judge in Fort Lauderdale to
reopen the case, which could affect 15 Florida counties
whose electronic voting terminals do not issue paper records.
It was not immediately unclear if the case could be decided
before the November 2 presidential election. The three-judge
panel in Atlanta wrote that U.S. District Judge James
Cohn misapplied a 35-year legal doctrine when he threw
out the lawsuit filed by Rep. Robert Wexler, D-Florida.
Wexler claims that paperless ballots cannot be recounted
as accurately as those cast on paper. He sued state election
officials, arguing that the Constitution would be violated
by a voting system that varies from county to county.
The
Center for Constitutional Litigation, along with Jeff Liggio,
an AAJ Governor from Florida, represent Congressman Wexler,
two county commissioners and a voter. The 11th Circuit's
decision allows the case to return to the federal district
court for the merits, where we are hoping to convince the
court that by adopting paperless touchscreen voting machines
in 15 Florida counties, while 52 other counties have optical
scan voting machines capable of manual recount, the elections
officials in Florida denied equal protection to the voters.
4.
ARBITRATION AGREEMENTS IN NURSING HOME ADMISSIONS BECOMING
WIDESPREAD
Leaders
in the nursing home industry claim that arbitration clauses
are needed to curb soaring litigation costs, while elder
law attorneys and consumer groups criticize the pacts
as self-serving industry weapons. Both sides agree, however,
that nursing home arbitration agreements are on the rise.
-
Nora Lockwood Tooher, Lawyers Weekly USA, 09/27/2004
For complete story, click
here
5.
WAIVERS OF RIGHT TO JURY TRIAL ON THE RISE
Agreements
to waive a party's right to a jury trial are becoming
increasingly common in a wide variety of settings, from
employment to credit card contracts, experts tell Lawyers
Weekly USA. While arbitration clauses remain a popular
choice for many businesses, the cost can serve as a deterrent.
-
Correy E. Stephenson, Lawyers Weekly USA, 09/27/2004
For complete story, click
here
6.
VOLLEYS OVER ASBESTOS FUND CONTINUE AS FRIST REJECTS LATEST
DASCHLE PROPOSAL
Senate
Majority Leader Bill Frist has rejected the latest Democratic
proposal for a privately funded trust fund for individuals
exposed to asbestos. In a letter to Minority Leader Tom
Daschle, Frist said Daschle's September 15 proposal for
a $140 billion no-fault compensation fund represents "too
little progress" on two major points: how to treat
claims already in the courts and how much money businesses
and insurers would contribute in the proposed fund's early
years. The two sides have exchanged a half-dozen proposals
and counteroffers since April, when Frist pulled from
the floor a bill to establish a $118 billion fund. In
the months since, the leaders have narrowed their differences
over the size of the fund. Frist's most recent plan
a $136 billion fund he proposed in July is almost
identical to Daschle's recent offer, when contributions
from the trusts of bankrupt asbestos manufacturers are
taken into account. But other outstanding issues remain
unresolved.
-
Seth Stern, CQ Today, 09/28/2004 For complete story,
see here
7.
ASBESTOS-RELATED SHARES FALL ON DIM FUND PROSPECTS
Shares
of companies facing asbestos claims fell after prospects
dimmed for establishing a victims' compensation fund this
year. Senate Republican Leader Bill Frist left the fund
off a list of priorities for the few days left in the
legislative period, which will end October 8. Shares of
chemical producer W.R. Grace and Co. fell 36 cents, or
$3.78, to $9.17, and the stock of car parts company Federal-Mogul
Corp., slid nearly 3 percent to 19 cents. Both companies
have filed for bankruptcy.
-
Reuters, 09/28/2004 For complete story, search here,
subscribers only
8.
UNDER A CLOUD; CASE HINGES ON MATERIAL WITNESS; IN A HIGH-STAKES
LAWSUIT AGAINST UNION CARBIDE, EXHIBIT A IS AN ASBESTOS
THE COMPANY NOW SAYS IS SAFE
To
hear Kelly-Moore's lawyer tell it, the Union Carbide salesmen
had their mantra down: Don't worry, they'd say, don't
worry. Union Carbide Corp. was one of the companies that
supplied Kelly-Moore Paint Co. of San Carlos, California,
with the asbestos used as a thickening agent in its products.
Union Carbide's trademarked Calidria was supposed to be
different from the asbestos sold by competitors such as
the former Johns-Manville Corp. But Kelly-Moore now claims
there was plenty to be worried about. Union Carbide, it
charges, fraudulently promoted Calidria as a uniquely
safe alternative to potentially deadly types of asbestos.
Kelly-Moore says Union Carbide had evidence linking the
product to cancer and asbestosis but withheld it. In a
high-stakes trial underway in state court in Angleton,
Texas (not far from Union Carbide's Houston headquarters),
Kelly-Moore is asking a jury to order the chemical giant
to take responsibility for a huge chunk of the paint company's
exposure to 48,000 asbestos injury suits. Kelly-Moore
wants actual damages of $1.3 billion - its anticipated
liabilities and legal costs - plus punitive damages of
$3.9 billion. Corporate customers are a new type of plaintiff
in a litigation blame game that has prompted more than
60 companies to seek bankruptcy protection. Until recently,
most asbestos suits were product-liability and wrongful-death
claims filed by individuals who blamed lung disease and
cancer on asbestos fibers they inhaled on the job and
in the home. Kelly-Moore's lawyer, Mark Lanier, told jurors
that they should, in fact, look back in time. In the 1950s,
he noted, Union Carbide was a member of the Industrial
Hygiene Foundation, which commissioned a study that linked
chrysotile, the type of asbestos sold by the company,
to cancer. But then the group publicly reported just the
opposite. And in the 1960s, he said, a few years after
Union Carbide discovered the world's largest cache of
asbestos in California and opened its mill near King City,
its own tests indicated that Calidria caused more damage
to the lungs of rats than the asbestos sold by Johns-Manville.
-
Lisa Girion, Los Angeles Times, 09/26/2004 For complete story, search
here, fees apply
- "Under
A Cloud; Once Surrounded By Asbestos, Now Surrounded
By Their Fears," Los Angeles Times, 09/25/2004.
For complete story, search
here, fees apply
The
AAJ Section on Toxic, Environmental and Pharmaceutical
Torts offers a list server news group, newsletters, networking
and much more. To find out more about joining the STEP Section,
call 800-424-2725, ext. 312, or visit http://www.justice.org/sections.
9.
HALLIBURTON MIGHT SELL KBR ONCE ASBESTOS SETTLEMENT DONE
Halliburton
Co. said it might sell or spin off KBR, its engineering
and construction services business, if its stock valuation
doesn't approach that of its peers after it completes
its asbestos settlement. KBR and a second Halliburton
unit - DII Industries - filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy
protection in December as part of a $4.2 billion settlement
of more than 400,000 asbestos and silica claims against
Halliburton. A U.S. District Court judge in July approved
the settlement, which is subject to appeals by insurance
companies. Driving the decision to keep or separate KBR
is Halliburton's eagerness to close the valuation gap
between itself and its peers in the oilfield services
sector, Chief Financial Officer Christopher Gaut said
during a conference with analysts and investors. Gaut
said Halliburton is discussing with plaintiffs' lawyers
how to share insurance proceeds that will be awarded starting
next year. Although those discussions could drag out,
he expects an agreement to be reached in the very near
term. The $1 billion insurance payment that Halliburton
is scheduled to receive in the first six months of 2005
will be put toward the $2.3 billion Halliburton has in
remaining settlement obligations.
-
David Bogoslaw, DowJones Newswires, 09/23/2004 For complete
story, search http://www.dowjonesnews.com Only subscribers
can access articles

US
Action has a new ad running in select TV markets about the
Halliburton asbestos bailout. To see the ad, go to their
Web site: http://www.usaction.org
10.
A.I.G. IS FOCUS OF FEDERAL INQUIRY
The
American International Group, one of the world's largest
insurance companies, said that the Justice Department
had begun a criminal investigation of one of its units
over possible violations of federal securities laws. A.I.G.
said in a statement that it believes the investigation
involved dealings between one subsidiary and PNC Financial
Services Group several years ago. The transactions enabled
PNC, a bank holding company, to shift $762 million in
loans from its balance sheet, according to court documents.
Such accounting maneuvers, which can make a company appear
financially stronger than it actually is, were at the
core of the Enron collapse and led to hundreds of millions
of dollars in penalties for financial-service companies.
The insurance company initially disclosed more than two
years ago that a subsidiary, the A.I.G. Financial Products
Corporation, had engaged in three transactions with PNC
after PNC was ordered by the Federal Reserve to restate
its earnings. Then in June of last year, PNC agreed to
pay $115 million in a fine and restitution in connection
with its accounting practices. A.I.G. said that its dealings
with PNC were under investigation by the Securities and
Exchange Commission. The company disclosed the Justice
Department investigation after the close of the stock
markets.
-
Joseph B. Treaster, The New York Times, 09/30/2004 For complete story, search
here, fees apply
11.
FDA WILL WARN ON ANTIDEPRESSANTS
The
Food and Drug Administration will require antidepressants
to carry warnings about the risk of increased suicidal
tendencies in young people, but hasn't made a final decision
on whether it will require the "black box" that
signifies its most serious concerns. Robert Temple, director
of the office of medical policy in the FDA's drug center,
told lawmakers the agency will "probably" call
for a black box on the label, but it also is considering
bold text without the box. The black- box warning, framed
in a literal box at the top of the label, can have a sharp
impact on how doctors prescribe drugs. Dr. Temple said
that a decision could be made within days, and that "in
a couple of weeks, you'll see the labeling change."
The FDA disclosed its plans in a hearing by a House Energy
and Commerce subcommittee, focusing on how the agency
has handled concerns that antidepressants could be linked
to suicidal tendencies in children and adolescents. Lawmakers
harshly questioned FDA officials about incidents stretching
back to 1996.
-
Anna Wilde Mathews, The Wall Street Journal, 09/24/2004.
For complete story, search
here, fees apply
The
AAJ Exchange offers a valuable resource to help you evaluate
your SSRI case...the Selective Serotonin Reuptake Inhibitors
(SSRIs) and the Link to Suicide Case Evaluation Kit. This
kit includes case abstracts and similar matters from the
Exchange database; court documents, a Medifocus guide, and
survey of medical and scientific literature; and other relevant
materials. For more information, visit http://www.justice.org/exchange,
or call 800-344-3023.
12.
LAW TO REIN IN HOSPITAL ERRORS IS SEEN AS ABUSED
Hospitals
routinely violate a New York State law requiring that
they tell the state promptly about medical errors that
harm patients, an audit said. The audit found that hospitals
often delay for weeks or months reports that might be
critical to a timely investigation, and sometimes never
report the mistakes at all. The audit, conducted by the
state comptroller, Alan G. Hevesi, found thousands of
instances in which hospitals failed to turn over prompt
information concerning episodes as serious as patient
deaths and mistaken surgery. But the State Health Department
punished the hospitals for the lapses only on a handful
of occasions, the audit concluded. In fact, Mr. Hevesi
said the department had failed to draw up and follow rules
detailing when and how to discipline the hospitals for
violations of the law. "The purpose of these reports
is to find problems, to correct them, and to save lives,"
he said. "You can't do that very well if you have
incomplete or inaccurate information."
-
Richard Pérez-Peña, The New York Times,
09/29/2004 For complete story, search
here, fees apply
13.
WILL MASSACHUSETTS COURT ALLOW EXPERT TO BE SUED?
Massachusetts'
highest court is set to decide just how much protection
physician experts hired by the state to review another
doctor's work will receive in the court system. The Supreme
Judicial Court of Massachusetts on October 5 is scheduled
to hear arguments in a case in which reviewed psychiatrist
Kennard C. Kobrin, MD, claims that he should be allowed
to sue hired expert doctor David R. Gastfriend, MD, an
addiction medicine specialist who critiqued his work for
the Board of Registration in Medicine. A lower court threw
out the lawsuit, saying that state laws protected Dr.
Gastfriend from being sued. Dr. Kobrin has asked the state's
highest court to allow him to go forward with the lawsuit,
which alleges that Dr. Gastfriend is liable for, among
other things, expert witness malpractice. One side says
a decision that prevents the lawsuit from advancing would
unfairly leave reviewed physicians without legal recourse.
"There has to be some right of the person being accused
to have redress," said George C. Deptula, the attorney
representing Dr. Kobrin. "This plays into medicine
being an art more than a science. Different people have
different views." The other side says a ruling from
the Supreme Judicial Court of Massachusetts allowing the
lawsuit to go forward would make it decidedly more difficult
to find physicians willing to offer their expertise in
peer review cases.
-
Tanya Albert, American Medical News, 10/04/2004 For
complete story, see
here
- "Tort
Reform Not The Answer," Island Packet, 09/28/2004
For complete story, see
here
14.
GOING TO THE WELL
Dallas
lawyer and former AAJ President Fred Baron has been asking
a court to freeze $70 million in his client's accounts
so his firm can get paid. In 2000, the city of Santa Monica
selected a team of lawyers, including Dallas Baron
and Budd, who promised they were ready to fight the war
of attrition with oil companies over contamination of
the city's water wells. Santa Monica settled most of its
lawsuits against the oil company last year. Its city attorneys
expressed satisfaction at how little court fighting the
case had required. They spoke too soon. Santa Monica now
looks to be warring with Baron and its other outside lawyers.
The lawyers say they are entitled to 25% of the city's
recovery. The oil companies agreed to pay $121 million
and to decontaminate the water themselves, a pledge worth
$240 million, according to one city expert. Rather than
pay the total fee request of $99 million, the city asked
a court to invalidate its contracts with the firms, accusing
their lawyers of malpractice and breach of fiduciary duty.
-
Matt Fleischer-Black, The American Lawyer, 09/27/2004
For complete story, search
here
15.
FLORIDA HIGH COURT OVERRULES GOVERNOR IN SCHIAVO CASE
Florida's
highest court ruled unanimously that Gov. Jeb Bush violated
a "cornerstone of American democracy" when he
overrode a court decision and ordered doctors to resume
tube-feeding a severely brain-damaged woman. Chief Justice
Barbara J. Pariente of the Florida Supreme Court called
Bush's actions in the case of Terri Schiavo "an encroachment
on the judicial branch" that undercut the constitutionally
protected separation of powers among the executive, legislative
and judicial branches. The decision does not mean that
Schiavo, who has been in a vegetative state since going
into cardiac arrest 14 years ago, will be immediately
removed from life-support systems, lawyers involved in
the case said. But the emphatically worded opinion leaves
a dwindling field of options for Bush, who has sided with
Schiavo's parents in a bruising legal battle to stop her
husband from having her disconnected from the feeding
tubes that are keeping her alive.
-
Manuel Roig-Franzia, Washington Post, 09/24/2004 For complete story, search
here, fees apply
16.
JAMES BEASLEY, 78, LAWYER IN BIG-JUDGMENT CASES, DIES
AAJ
member James E. Beasley, a lawyer who won millions of
dollars in jury verdicts in major cases, including an
unpaid $104 million judgment stemming from the September
11, 2001, attacks, died on September 25 at a hospital
in Philadelphia. He was 78 and lived in Villanova, Pennsylvania.
His death was announced by the Beasley Firm, a 16-lawyer
office he formed in 1966. As its principal partner, he
remained active, said his son, James E. Beasley Jr., a
member of the firm who lives in West Chester, Pennsylvania.
The firm won wide notice with one of the first suits brought
for families of September 11 victims. The suit, filed
in Federal District Court in Manhattan just over a month
after the attacks, named as defendants Osama bin Laden,
Al Qaeda, Afghanistan, its Taliban rulers and the Iraqi
government. The action won a finding of liability and
a $104 million judgment last year. By then, the money,
confiscated by the United States, had been allocated to
rebuild Iraq, and the judgment remains unpaid. On the
other hand, clients of the firm collected on scores of
million-dollar judgments, including some of largest settlements
in the state, cases like catastrophic brain-injury and
neonatal malpractice cases; aviation and product liability
suits; and suits over a recalled cholesterol treatment,
Baycol; the fen-phen class of combination diet drugs;
and other pharmaceuticals.
-
Wolfgang Saxon, The New York Times, 09/24/2004 For complete story, search
here, fees apply
17.
3M, FIVE OTHERS TO PAY IMPLANT SETTLEMENT
3M
Co., Dow Chemical and four other companies that made breast
implants have agreed to pay the U.S. government $11.3
million in a settlement that will reimburse Medicare for
costs associated with treating several women who became
ill after receiving silicone breast implants. Silicone
implants, which have been banned since 1992, have been
blamed for an array of illnesses that affected some women's
auto-immune systems. The settlement is part of a larger
$1 billion settlement with implant makers that took place
back in 1995. The $11.3 million agreement marks the final
chapter in a Department of Justice lawsuit filed in 2000
that demanded that funds be taken from the 1995 $1 billion
settlement to reimburse Medicare for treating implant-related
injuries. 2004 WL 91249711.
-
Minneapolis-St. Paul Star Tribune, Westlaw Highlights,
09/23/2004. For complete story, see
here Westlaw password required or variable fees
of $4 and up are charged for article retrieval
The
AAJ Products Liability Law Reporter contains names and
locations of plaintiff's counsel and of both sides' liability
experts, federal and state case law, and verdict and settlement
information. Subscribers also receive free membership in
AAJ's Products Liability Section. To subscribe, call 800-424-2727,
or go to http://www.justice.org/publications.
18.
NHTSA SAYS STABILITY CONTROL HELPS PREVENT ROLLOVERS
A
technology to prevent vehicle rollovers got a major boost
from a federal study showing it reduced fatal sport-utility
vehicle crashes by 63% and fatal car crashes by 30%. Electronic
stability control (ESC) detects when a vehicle is not
heading in the direction a driver intends and uses brakes
and engine power to bring it under control. It can be
especially helpful in emergency maneuvers or on slippery
or gravel surfaces. Automakers and regulators have been
focusing on ways to prevent rollovers, which accounted
for 10,376 deaths last year, about a third of fatalities
in vehicles. Altering a vehicle's width and center of
gravity can influence its chance of tipping.
-
Jayne O'Donnell, USA Today, 09/24/2004 For complete story, search
here, fees apply
19.
NO ESCAPING OXYCONTIN FEE FRENZY
Due
to Purdue Pharma's "take no prisoners" stance
in hundreds of OxyContin product liability suits across
the country, the company has yet to pay 1 cent to plaintiffs.
But now, at least one insurer is trying to litigate a
way out of paying the multimillion-dollar legal bills
created by those aggressive defense tactics. In a first-impression
ruling in Connecticut, Judge Taggart D. Adams has blocked
Steadfast Insurance's bid to limit damages related to
suits over the controversial painkiller.
-
The Connecticut Law Tribune, Law.com, 09/27/2004 For complete
story, search here, subscribers
only
20.
HELPING THE UNTOLD VICTIMS OF 9/11
As
a roll of those killed during the 9/11 terrorist attacks
was read during recent memorial events, Beaufort attorney
Jeff Newton recalled the victims whose names were not
heard. Along with the 3,000 killed, there were survivors
left with physical injuries and emotional scars, Newton
said. "One of the things that people don't realize
is that there were more injuries than there were deaths,"
he said. Newton is well acquainted with the stories of
two survivors. He handled their injury claims as part
of the largest pro bono project in the nation's history.
Newton was one of about 1,100 attorneys nationwide and
about 60 in North Carolina who volunteered their time
and expertise to assist victims of the 9/11 attacks in
New York, Pennsylvania and at the Pentagon. TLC President
Richard Bieder of Connecticut said it was a massive undertaking
by attorneys across the country who essentially came together
as the "largest law firm in the world" to represent
1,745 claimants before the federal Victim Compensation
Fund set up after 9/11. Bieder estimates TLC attorneys
put in an average of 150 to 200 hours of their time per
case, and he knows from the many calls he made to recruit
help that they did so with no questions asked.
-
Jannette Pippin, Jacksonville Daily News, 09/16/2004
For complete story, see
here
DALLAS
MORNING NEWS SERIES: EFFECTS OF PROPOSITION 12 ON TEXAS
21.
LAWYERS CAUGHT BETWEEN CLIENTS, MALPRACTICE CAP
AAJ
member and Dallas attorney Paula Sweeney asked a roomful
of lawyers in July how many had filed a medical malpractice
lawsuit since Proposition 12 went into effect. Three hands
went up out of 300 at a Dallas seminar on medical malpractice.
At a San Antonio seminar, four hands out of 400 went up.
"It's not lawyers saying, 'We can't make enough money,'"
said Ms. Sweeney. "It's lawyers saying, 'Look at
it: They've [Texas lawmakers] made the system impossible.'"
Voters narrowly approved the amendment, despite warnings
from lawyers that many Texans could lose their day in
court. A year later, "it has turned out exactly as
we said it would," Ms. Sweeney said. AAJ member
Les Weisbrod, a Dallas attorney who has handled many malpractice
cases, said he's trying to pursue cases that others might
turn down. "I'm trying not to turn those cases down
because I think that's what the insurance companies and
the right-wing fanatics within the medical profession
wanted," Mr. Weisbrod said, "and I don't want
to let them win." Plaintiffs' attorneys say the caps
hurt the most defenseless Texans old people, children,
homemakers and others who have little or no economic damages
to recover. Fort Worth attorney Randy Moore said the cap
on damages "is turning out exactly the way the insurance
company, big business and special interests wanted, exactly
like the lawyers feared and totally different than what
the doctors thought because they're not getting any breaks
on this. It's just made the insurance companies more powerful."
-
Terry Maxon, The Dallas Morning News, 09/25/2004 For complete story, search
here
- "No
Cure-All: Time Hasn't Healed Controversy Over Caps On
Damages," The Dallas Morning News, 09/25/2004.
For complete story, search
here
- "Doctors
Still Awaiting Lower Rates," The Dallas Morning
News, 09/25/2004 For complete story, search
here
- "Cap
Slows Patient's Lawsuit," The Dallas Morning News,
09/25/2004 For complete story, search
here
22.
VOTERS IN FOUR STATES TO PASS JUDGMENT ON DOCTOR-VS-LAWYER
DISPUTE OVER MALPRACTICE AWARDS
Doctors
and trial lawyers are squaring off this fall in an unprecedented
four-state struggle over limiting malpractice awards.
The volatile issue is in voters' hands and each side is
desperate to win, spending millions of dollars to make
their cases and portray the other side as greedy. In all
four states - Florida, Nevada, Oregon and Wyoming - doctors
and health insurers pushed to get measures on the November
2 ballot, and trial lawyers are campaigning hard for a
"No" vote. "The insurance industry, the
drug industry, the hospital and nursing home industry
have far more money than people injured by medical malpractice
and their lawyers," said Carlton Carl of the American Association for Justice. "But if there's a level
playing field, I have no doubt Americans will vote to
preserve their legal rights." The American Medical
Association has been lobbying tenaciously for federal
legislation, supported by President Bush, that would place
a nationwide $250,000 cap on non-economic damage awards.
Those are awards for pain and emotional distress as opposed
to awards for medical bills, lost wages and other quantifiable
costs. The four ballot proposals differ from each other:
Wyoming's is a proposed constitutional amendment that
would allow lawmakers to place a not-yet- determined cap
on non-economic losses. Oregon's would cap non-economic
awards at $500,000. In Florida, where lawmakers imposed
a $500,000 cap last year, the proposal would limit lawyers'
share of any malpractice settlement to 30 percent at most,
less in the case of large awards. Nevada's measure would
remove all exemptions from an existing $350,000 cap, and
also limit attorney fees.
-
David Crary, The Associated Press, 09/26/2004 For complete story, search
here
23.
HOUSE VOTES TO BRING BITE BACK TO RULE 11
When
it comes to rule-making, the Judicial Conference of the
United States generally has the corner on what works best
in the federal courts. But in what one scholar deems an
attempt at "tort reform through the back door,"
the U.S. House of Representatives has resurrected and
approved a rule on attorney sanctions that the conference,
as well as most academics, judges and lawyers, believed
had been justly interred in the old-rule graveyard more
than a decade ago.
-
The National Law Journal, Law.com, 09/27/2004 For complete
story, search here, subscribers
only
- "Dispute
Goes To Voters: Malpractice Suit Limits Are On The November
Ballot In Four States," 2004 WL 92456669. Ft. Lauderdale
Sun-Sentinel, Westlaw Highlights, 09/27/2004 For complete
story, see
here Westlaw password required or variable fees
of $4 and up are charged for article retrieval
24.
HEADSET PHONES MAY STILL POSE RISKS FOR DRIVERS
Evidence
is mounting that talking on a cellphone while driving
can be risky, even when using the increasingly popular
"hands-free" devices. Drivers account for roughly
40% of all cellphone use and, because of safety concerns,
the use of headsets is exploding in popularity. Hands-free
devices are now required in New York, New Jersey, Washington,
D.C., and many towns around the country. A batch of scientific
papers presented at the annual meeting of the Human Factors
and Ergonomics Society in New Orleans raised safety questions
about voice- activated dialing, including a study funded
by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration
that was first reported by The Wall Street Journal in
a page-one article in July that raised questions about
the increased safety of hands-free devices. Perhaps the
most provocative findings presented at the meeting came
from researchers at the University of Utah, who presented
two studies. One experiment, presented by psychology professor
Frank Drews, compared a group of drivers who talked on
a cellphone with another group that talked to a passenger
sitting next to them. The researchers put 48 college students
in a driving simulator. Half of the students drove while
having conversations with friends on cellphones equipped
with headsets. The other half talked to a friend sitting
in the passenger seat. All of the students also drove
another round unaccompanied, without talking on the phone.
Overall, 12 of the 24 drivers in the group talking on
the phone missed their exit, a rate four times as high
as the drivers who were talking to their passengers -
and 12 times as high as while they were driving alone
without talking to anyone.
-
Jesse Drucker, The Wall Street Journal, 09/24/2004 For complete story, search
here, fees apply
25.
COURTS TO DETERMINE RELEASE OF VEHICLE SAFETY DATA
Pleasing
automakers and frustrating consumer advocates, the government
is keeping the public in the dark about vehicle safety
data. National Highway Traffic Safety Administration officials
compiled extensive data on deaths, injuries, consumer
complaints, property damage and warranty claims following
demands from Congress stemming from the 2000 recall of
Firestone Tires. Now, the NHTSA is waiting for a court
ruling that will determine exactly what type of data should
be made public.
-
The Associated Press, Law.com, 09/27/2004 For complete
story, search here, subscribers
only
|
OTHER
STORIES OF INTEREST |
26.
LINKS
- "The
Making Of The Corporate Judiciary," Michael Scherer,
MotherJones.com, November/December 2003 Issue. For complete
story, search
here
- "Award
In Smoking Case Is Cut," 2004 WL 55938926 Los Angeles
Times, Westlaw Highlights, 09/22/2004 For complete story,
see
here Westlaw password required or variable fees
of $4 and up are charged for article retrieval
27.
GLASS-DOOR WALL CABINETS
The
U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission (CPSC) and IKEA
Home Furnishings, of Plymouth Meeting, Pennsylvania, are
recalling about 25,000 BERTBY Glass-Door Wall Cabinets.
Some of these glass-door wall cabinets have the wrong
sized screws for the safety bracket, which can result
in the cabinet not being properly secured to the wall.
The cabinets can fall and injure nearby consumers.
28.
PACIFIERS
The
CPSC and Natura Products Downey Inc., of City of Commerce,
California are recalling about 9,400 Jaloma pacifiers.
The pacifiers are banned under federal law. They failed
federal safety tests, come apart and can pose a choking
hazard to infants and small children.
29.
TV/VCR CARTS
The
CPSC and Sauder Woodworking Co., of Archbold, Ohio are
recalling about 300,000 TV/VCR carts. The carts can tip
over, and the television can fall off, posing a risk of
serious injury or death if the TV and cart fall on a child.
30.
ATVS
The
CPSC and Polaris Industries, Inc., of Medina, Minnesota
are recalling about 12,170 Polaris "Sportsman 700
EFI" ATVs. The throttle cable may bind when the handlebars
are turned full left or full right, resulting in an increase
in engine speed and unintended vehicle acceleration. In
addition, the fuel line may rub against the vehicle chassis,
resulting in a fuel line leak, which could be a fire hazard.
You
can access information about product recalls on the Consumer
Product Safety Commission (CPSC) website.
To report a dangerous product, email
the CPSC or call Eric Stone, Director, Compliance Legal
Division of CPSC, (301) 504-0626 ext. 1350 |