No. 03-15884, 11th Circuit Court of Appeals (filed
March 25, 2004).
This
is an admiralty case arising out of a steam boiler
explosion aboard the S/S NORWAY as it was docked
in Miami. Six seamen, all citizens of the Philippines,
were killed and four were severely burned. Plaintiffs
brought an action under the Jones Act, alleging
negligence and unseaworthiness of the vessel. The
owners of the vessel moved to dismiss on the basis
that the seamen had signed contracts which provided
that all claims were to be arbitrated in the Philippines.
The district court granted the motion, following
a recent 5th Circuit decision in a similar case.
AAJ
and Trial Lawyers for Public Justice submitted a
joint amicus brief, written by CCL's Senior Amicus
Counsel Jeffrey White and TLPJs Kate Gordon,
arguing that the intent of Congress in enacting
the Jones Act was to safeguard the rights of seamen,
traditional wards of the courts, from overreaching
by shipowner employers. The brief also argued that
the arbitration provisions are also void and unenforceable
because they leave plaintiffs without any remedy
at all for their tort claims against the vessel
owner.
AAJ's
Amicus Curiae Brief: Bautista
v. Star Cruises and Norwegian Cruise Line, Ltd.